@Khometmibro The verse is clearly denying anyone teaching the prophet ﷺ and is making an argument against it. That the Qurʾān is so Eloquent so a foreign guy CAN'T come up with something like it. It's directed to the Quraish because they were challenged themselves & FAILED and they're Arabs.
@Khometmibro بمعنى ما تلحدون إليه لن يسعفكم لأنه أعجمي من المستحيل أن يأتي بمثل القرآن الكريم وأنتم كعرب أقحاح فشلتم في ذلك. أيضاً في الروايات الحديثية هذا الغلام قال بأنه هو من يتعلم من النبي ﷺ و أسلم بعدها.
@Khometmibro The Tafsir and reports about it is that the guy was a young slave.
Thus can't have such knowledge in the first place.
Also the owner of the slave went to him and started beating him and asked him :
Thus can't have such knowledge in the first place.
Also the owner of the slave went to him and started beating him and asked him :
@Khometmibro "do you teach Muhammad ﷺ?" The slave answered :"no, but he is the one who's teaching me and guiding me".
We have reports that he converted to islam as well.
Which defeats the entire argument.
We have reports that he converted to islam as well.
Which defeats the entire argument.
@Khometmibro If he converted to islam it means he believed islam to be the truth which means he didn't teach the prophet ﷺ things that he didn't know.
@Khometmibro Not to mention that all of this isn't necessarily to defeat the accusation. Because the burden of proof is upon the one accusing the prophet ﷺ. They should provide proof not mere accusations. But these points suffice to refute this specific one.
@Khometmibro You have this in شعب الإيمان by imam al-Bayhaqī reported from ibn Abbas (RA) saying he converted to islam. Volume 1 page 125.
@Khometmibro The same is mentioned in Tafsir al-Baghawi of the Ayah.
@Khometmibro And you have the following reported in Tafsir al-Qurtubi on the ayah.
"The craftsman mentioned that the master of Jabr would strike him and say, "You are teaching Muhammad!" to which he would respond, "No, by God, it is he who teaches and guides me."
"The craftsman mentioned that the master of Jabr would strike him and say, "You are teaching Muhammad!" to which he would respond, "No, by God, it is he who teaches and guides me."
Loading suggestions...