#SupremeCourt to shortly hear a batch of petitions concerning #ManipurViolence
The bench would be apprised of the probe in the #ManipurVideo case and other cases of violence against common citizens
The bench would be apprised of the probe in the #ManipurVideo case and other cases of violence against common citizens
As earlier ordered by the Supreme Court, the Director General of Police Manipur is personally present in the apex court today for hearing #ManipurViolence #SupremeCourtofIndia
AG R Venkataramani: In terms of the SC order: regarding disaggregation of offences. As on today we have to be careful. The govt is handling this at a very mature level.
#ManipurViolence #SupremeCourtofIndia
#ManipurViolence #SupremeCourtofIndia
AG: There is a small suggestion.. please see our note
CJI: Mr AG please see the first two pages so that we have a birds eye view..
AG: i will come back to those pages..
#ManipurViolence #SupremeCourtofIndia
CJI: Mr AG please see the first two pages so that we have a birds eye view..
AG: i will come back to those pages..
#ManipurViolence #SupremeCourtofIndia
AG: in case of murders: it will be investigated by SP and other senior officers. for sexual offences there will be woman officers. For other offences it will be DySP etc..
there will be 6 SITs in each district where there was violence...
#ManipurViolence #SupremeCourtofIndia
there will be 6 SITs in each district where there was violence...
#ManipurViolence #SupremeCourtofIndia
AG: The situation is still sensitive...any external probe may be...
CJI: You said CBI will be investigating 11 cases. Has that number been altered?
SG Mehta: if something is found out during investigation of 11...FIRs relating to rape etc- those are to be dealt with by SITs…
CJI: You said CBI will be investigating 11 cases. Has that number been altered?
SG Mehta: if something is found out during investigation of 11...FIRs relating to rape etc- those are to be dealt with by SITs…
SG: In the CBI team.. it is here as well.. there will be 11 plus one FIR.. the team has two SP level officers.. CBI has officers from all across the country from all states
CJI: Any suggestion from the other side
AG: Peace must be unconditional.. any process to weaken it must…
CJI: Any suggestion from the other side
AG: Peace must be unconditional.. any process to weaken it must…
Adv Vrinda Grover: on the note just been given... the reason why there is a concern about the nature of the investigation..
SG: Which is this thing being read
Grover: just given to us
SG: How many pages document..
Grover: 24..
CJI: What is this secret document being shared…
SG: Which is this thing being read
Grover: just given to us
SG: How many pages document..
Grover: 24..
CJI: What is this secret document being shared…
Adv Grover: all incidents mentioned here in fall under Imphal.. the police station is Imphal and the district is also Imphal... most of the victims are not in Imphal.. who will be the jurisdictional magistrate.. victims are in churachandpur or in other camps.. then in one case it…
Sr Adv Indira Jaising: one is on investigation and one is prevention.. conflict is ongoing.. my concern is proper probe of crimes which have occured and prevention of other crimes. please see how the prevention aspect has been dealt with by this court.. #ManipurViolence
Sr Adv Jaising: one is a high powered commission which will report to this court... a commission consisting of retired female judges of this court is in the nature of eyes and ears of this court.. give any names you like.. mandate is to prevent sexual violence.. it started on May…
Jaising: the SIT could have women police officers of unblemished record taken from outside the state.. #ManipurViolence
Sr Adv Jaising: recording of statement under Section 164.. I had submitted that rape victims do not like repeating their ordeal... women magistrates can be assigned for recording of statements..
Sr Adv Jaising refers to a SC case
Sr Adv Jaising refers to a SC case
AG: Artificial created scenes here to show that reluctance on part of the govt to not hand over the bodies.. but situation on ground is different
SG: It is a coincidence that just a day before hearing in this court something big happens there... I do not know how this is…
SG: It is a coincidence that just a day before hearing in this court something big happens there... I do not know how this is…
Adv Vishal Tiwari submits prayers in his plea: A SIT headed by a former SC judge should probe in this case and also ensure that the Lalita Kumari judgment is followed #ManipurViolence
Adv Nizam Pasha: There are not 11 FIRs but 16 now.. we have furnished the list to the SG office..
SG: We have analysed and we have seen that it is 11 FIRs only
#ManipurViolence
SG: We have analysed and we have seen that it is 11 FIRs only
#ManipurViolence
Pasha: there is a selection of case bias and progress of case bias is also seen here in the report of the state government towards a community. that is why a SIT overseen by court appointed judges committee needs to be there
#ManipurViolence
#ManipurViolence
Adv Prashant Bhushan: there was a looting of arms and ammunitions from the state armoury has to be seen if it happened with state involvement
SG: It is being investigated by someone else..
#ManipurViolence
SG: It is being investigated by someone else..
#ManipurViolence
Sr Adv Colin Gonsalves: when riots take place.. we need to identify the core ring leaders.. the investigation or the core part must focus on the 6,000 FIRs but also on the core persons who created and executed the conspiracy.. once the core elements are caught.. once they are…
SG: It may not be appropriate to trust the police department at this stage. let the committee not have civil society members but only judicial officers. #ManipurViolence
Sr Adv Sanjay Hegde: there are two choke points.. National highway 2 and Assam border.. if its released.. a lot of tension will go down.. Manipur is still something we are all concerned with... this would be a good first step #ManipurViolence
An adv from Manipur: let the violence be stopped. kids are taken from school.. national highways are blocked.. everything has become costly.. nobody is earning... forget displaced persons.. what about common people.. just submitting applications will not help. let the petitioners…
Adv: everyday FIRs are increasing and this 6,000 FIR will become 10,000 after one month.. what will the court then? that is why violence needs to be stopped #SupremeCourt
SG: There are reasons why we are not discussing here.. there are cross border issues etc
#BREAKING CJI DY Chandrachud: We will dictate our order in the evening, it is already 3:25 pm. The broad outline is to use whatever in our power is to restore faith in rule of law.. we will appoint a committee of 3 former HC judges. this committee of three judges will look at the…
#BREAKING CJI DY Chandrachud: On the investigation.. you have transferred it to the CBI. We will not supplant the CBI since it is looking at it. But to ensure faith in rule of law.. we are not casting aspersion on CBI..We are proposing to direct that there shall be 5 officers of…
CJI DY Chandrachud: we have identified a former police officer who will head another layer of supervision who will report back to us. So far as state investigation is concerned there will be about 42 SITs which will look at cases not transferred to CBI... you have said murder…
#Breaking #ManipurViolence
CJI: Committee of 3 former judges.: headed by Justice Gita Mittal, Justice Shalini Joshi, Justice Asha Menon
The former police officer will be Dattatray Padsalgikar
CJI: Committee of 3 former judges.: headed by Justice Gita Mittal, Justice Shalini Joshi, Justice Asha Menon
The former police officer will be Dattatray Padsalgikar
CJI: one suggestion is that offences must be registered under the correct sections.. we will look at other recommendations.. whichever we deem fit we will include..we also have a feel for realities.. it may be premature for shifting of trial since we are still at the stage of…
CJI: All adequate security should be provided for the committee headed by Justice Mittal.
SG: It shall be done certainly
#ManipurViolence
SG: It shall be done certainly
#ManipurViolence
Loading suggestions...